■ CASE 05 · 1992 · RENO

ROOM 312

A poker dealer strangled in a locked hotel room on tournament night. A drifter did twenty-six years for it. The casino's tapes have a forty-minute hole.

Difficulty●●●●○ 4/5
Play time3 hours
Players1–8
Documents26 · 3 envelopes, the last one sealed
PriceFree
Room 312 — Silverado Hotel & Casino, Reno, Nevada, 1992

The case

At 04:30 on 14 February 1992 a cocktail waitress found poker dealer Gary Sutter strangled in room 312 of the Silverado. His wallet and watch were gone. A drifter who pawned the watch was convicted within the year. In 2017 a reporter noticed the casino's surveillance log had a forty-minute gap that night, signed off as "maintenance". Nobody at trial had asked who signed it.

What the file will make you work out

  1. Whether the convicted man could have done it
  2. How the door opened without a key
  3. Who to accuse, and why

What is in the file

  • Reno PD case summary
  • Newspaper clippings (1992, 2017)
  • Scene report and floor plan
  • Medical examiner's report
  • Seven scene photographs
  • Six statements
  • Electronic door log
  • Poker room layout
  • The dealer's notebook
  • Pawn ticket and dumpster log
  • Police booking record
  • Surveillance tape log
  • Four more documents in Envelope 2
  • The solution file

Persons of interest

  • Eddie Kane — Drifter
  • Celia Ruiz — Cocktail waitress
  • Marty Feld — Poker room manager
  • Ray Whitcomb — Surveillance supervisor
  • Dale "Tex" Pruitt — High-stakes player

Questions about this case

Is Room 312 really free?

Yes. The whole case is free in your browser: all documents and the sealed solution. No sign-up, no payment, nothing is mailed.

How long does Room 312 take?

About 3 hours for two to four people. Solo players take longer. Progress is saved, so you can stop and come back.

Can I play with friends who are not in the room?

Yes. Open a room, share the 5-letter code, and everyone reads the file on their own phone. Pins, notes and the timeline stay in sync. Nobody needs an account.

What if we get stuck?

There are no hints. Re-read the statements against the records, compare times and names, and use your notes and timeline. When you accuse, right or wrong, the sealed solution explains what the file proved.

Is the answer checked?

Yes. Your accusation is checked on our server; the solution is not in the page, so it cannot be read in advance.

More cold case files

← Previous case: The Lighthouse KeeperNext case: The Orchard →

The Boathouse — Fenwick Point, Connecticut01
CASE 01 · 1996 · CONNECTICUT

The Boathouse

A journalism intern, a boathouse, and a watchman who has been in prison for twenty years.

Last Departure — Great Lakes Overnight, Chicago → Boston02
CASE 02 · 1988 · CHICAGO UNION STATION

Last Departure

An architect dies in a sleeper compartment bolted from the inside. The coroner said heart attack.

Unidentified — Salvo, Hatteras Island, North Carolina03
CASE 03 · 2003 · OUTER BANKS, NC

Unidentified

A burned body in the dunes. No name, no witnesses. First find out who she was.

The Lighthouse Keeper — Sorrow Point Light, Hancock County, Maine04
CASE 04 · 1979 · MAINE

The Lighthouse Keeper

A keeper dead at the foot of his tower, the hatch above him bolted from inside. The county said he fell. The log says a boat came.

The Orchard — Coyle Ridge Orchards, Chelan County, Washington06
CASE 06 · 1985 · WASHINGTON

The Orchard

A picker crushed under a bin trailer at the height of the harvest. An accident, the sheriff said. Two ledgers for the same week say otherwise.

Play free

All case files